Career Development
  Articles and Advice
ASCAP Corner

Cue Sheet Corner

Feature Articles

Keen on Music Publishing

Murphy's Laws of Songwriting

Music & Money

Music, Money, Success & Movies

Zen and the Art of A&R



  Collaborator Corner
Events Calendar
Resource Guide
Showcases
Support
Workshops

ASCAP Network
Songwriter/Composer Portal
ASCAP Playback Magazine
Customer Licencees
Legislation
ASCAP Jam
ASCAP Store
Articles & Advice

Feature Articles

ALAN AND MARILYN BERGMAN ON SONGWRITING: PART 3

The following is excerpted from the Bergmans' guest spot at the ASCAP Extended Songwriters' Workshop, held in November, 1996.

Have you ever written something for a film that you felt very strongly about, and then the director said that it wasn't working for him?

MB: Oh yes, many times. If someone doesn't like something, you can't make them like it. You're working for the director, and that's the vision that rules the world of the picture. And rather than ask, "What don't you like?", you're better off just starting over. It's happened many times -- more times than I'd like to remember!

Do you ever come up with something that you think is great, and then worry that you've actually subconsciously taken it from somewhere else?

"If it sounds tired or sounds like something that we've heard before, that's when we say to each other, 'No, we can do better.'"

MB: I think it's the same thing that composers do -- I can't tell you how often a composer has said to us, "Does this sound like anything else?", because they're afraid that they've awoken with a melody, but it's something that they're unconsciously remembering that they heard somewhere else. So just as a composer wants to be sure that they're not repeating something -- not consciously stealing it, but taking from something that's been written before. I really don't know. I just know that if it sounds tired or sounds like something that we've heard before, that's when we say to each other, "No, we can do better."

Do you find that if you're writing for a certain singer, you tailor your images to the way that they're going to sing?

AB: If you're writing a song in a dramatic context, you have several masters that you have to try to satisfy -- all of them! When you have a singer with a real instrument, you have to be sure that you're always putting open sounds on high notes, and that you're never giving the singer "mouthfuls", so they will have the chance to open up and sing. That's from a stylistic standpoint. From a content standpoint, I don't think it comes into play when you're writing for a dramatic piece, because you're writing for the character, and the artist is that character. But when you're writing for an artist, you know that there are certain ideas or sentiments that are either becoming or unbecoming, or appropriate for that person, whether it's a question of age or ethnicity or who knows what. If you're writing for Sinatra, it's like writing for a character in a movie -- he's not some anonymous singer who changes with every song: you know exactly what you're writing with him. And songwriters have given certain singers character -- those songs which are signature songs by which the public identifies them, like roles that actors play.

When you're writing on deadline, how do you know yourself when you're finished?

MB: When they take it away from you! Really! Given time, we'll use every minute we have -- give us a month, we'll take a month; give us a week, we'll take a week, and we'll never think that it's finished until then. When did Picasso know he'd done that last stroke on the canvas?

How do you test your material outside of your own collaboration?

MB: Our daughter is our best critic. She's very honest, and very smart.

How did you become so involved in ASCAP?

AB: We were ASCAP writers from the get-go. It was unthinkable not to be in the company of these great writers: it was the society of Johnny Mercer, Irving Berlin, Ira and George Gershwin, Richard Rodgers, Harold Arlen, Jerome Kern, and so many others.

MB: I never dreamed I'd be elected to the Board. It was strange for awhile: I was the first woman to serve, and I was also the youngest person there. I was on the Board through Morton Gould's presidency, and since I've always been very involved in politics, I had a role to play as an ASCAP Board Member in Washington. As the legislative picture became more and more complicated, as it became more and more clear that our fates were being decided in the halls of Congress, and issues of copyright became more complicated and dangerous, I found myself getting more and more involved with the legislative aspect of songwriters' interests.

When Morton, who was then 81, decided to step down, I was approached and asked if I would assume the presidency. I felt that if I was ever going to do it, perhaps this was the right time, in terms of what it was that I could bring. Now is a very dangerous time, with the explosion of technology, and the long-accepted rules governing the concepts of intellectual property and the sanctity of copyright being shot down, even as we speak, by people who feel that it all should be free. We're really fighting for our lives, and I'm not being overly dramatic.

Has there been any discussion of taking a large number of writers down to Washington and really making our presence felt?

MB: Yes, we are, and we will continue to do that. There's a great value to taking four or five writers and actually having one-on-one meetings with the leadership. The opposition is formidable.

"We have to let [the legislators] know that there are very, very few millionaire songwriters, and the five-six-eight thousand dollars that you might get a year in performances is sometimes the difference between rent or no rent, or sending your kid to college or not."

AB: Write your Congressman, and answer the call when ASCAP needs your voice.

MB: Yes, but more important is your presence, to tell your story, and to let them know that there are very, very few millionaire songwriters, and the five-six-eight thousand dollars that you might get a year in performances is sometimes the difference between rent or no rent, or sending your kid to college, or whatever.

What kind of noise can we make to effect changes in Washington?

MB: That's a good question. If you really are serious about that, I think that nothing has been as effective as bringing songwriters into the halls of Congress, and into state legislatures. I think that it's far more important for them to meet writers who have not yet happened, because when they think of songwriters, they think of huge performer/writers like Michael Jackson, Bruce Springsteen and Madonna, and they don't realize that most songwriters are struggling, and the lions' share of the money comes from performances. I think that if we have the names and addresses of those of you who would be willing to join us in Washington and walk the halls of Congress, I can't tell you how important that is.

[See ASCAP Legislative Matters for furtherinformation on current issues.]

Return to Part 1 >>>


TOP

Read Playback Magazine, serving the world of songwriters, composers and music publishers.
HOME | ACE TITLE SEARCH | NEWS
Join ASCAP | About ASCAP | ASCAPLatino | CONTACT US | SITE MAP
FOR MEMBERS | CAREER DEVELOPMENT | SONGWRITER/COMPOSER PORTAL | CUSTOMER LICENSEES
LEGISLATION | ASCAP JAM | JOBS @ ASCAP | ASCAP STORE

Logos / Licensed Marks | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | ASCAP RSS Headline & Podcast Feeds
Reproduction or use of audio, video, editorial or pictorial content in any manner is strictly prohibited
without express written permission from ASCAP.
© 2008 ASCAP